Who is caring for the underserved? A comparison of primary care physicians and nonphysician clinicians

  • Abstract

    PURPOSE: Little is known about whether different types of physician and nonphysician primary care clinicians vary in their propensity to care for underserved populations. The objective of this study was to compare the geographic distribution and patient populations of physician and nonphysician primary care clinicians.

    METHODS: This study was a cross-sectional analysis of 1998 administrative and survey data on primary care clinicians (family physicians, general internists, general pediatricians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and certified nurse-midwives) in California and Washington. For geographic analysis, main outcome measures were practice in a rural area, a vulnerable population area (communities with high proportions of minorities or low-income residents), or a health professions shortage area (HPSA). For patient population analysis, outcomes were the proportions of Medicaid, uninsured, and minority patients in the practice.

    RESULTS: Physician assistants ranked first or second in each state in the proportion of their members practicing in rural areas and HPSAs, and in California physician assistants also had the greatest proportion of their members working in vulnerable populations areas (P < .001). Compared with primary care physicians overall, nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives also tended to have a greater proportion of their members in rural areas and HPSAs (P < .001). Family physicians were much more likely than other primary care physicians to work in rural areas and HPSAs (P < .001). Compared with physicians, nonphysician clinicians in California had a substantially greater proportion of Medicaid, uninsured, and minority patients (P < .001).

    CONCLUSIONS: Nonphysician primary care clinicians and family physicians have a greater propensity to care for underserved populations than do primary care physicians in other specialties. Achieving a more equitable pattern of service to needy populations will require ongoing, active commitment by policy makers, educational institutions, and the professions to a mission of public service and to incentives that support and promote care to the underserved.

  • Authors:

    Grumbach K, Hart LG, Mertz E, Coffman J, Palazzo L

  • Journal/Publisher:

    Ann Fam Med

  • Edition:

    Jan 2003. 1(2):97-104

  • Link to Article

    Access the article here: Ann Fam Med

  • Citation:

    Grumbach K, Hart LG, Mertz E, Coffman J, Palazzo L. Who Is Caring For The Underserved? A Comparison Of Primary Care Physicians And Nonphysician Clinicians Ann Fam Med. Jan 2003 1(2):97-104

  • Related Studies:

    The Contribution of Generalist Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants to Primary Care in Rural Washington State